I'm watching Letterman because Barack Obama is a guest tonight. I sure enjoy watching our eloquent president speak. It was also nice to check back in on Dave's show after so much time away.
Let's talk about Dave Letterman for a minute.
I was thinking about it. We lost out as a television audience when NBC chose Leno over Dave. The Tonight Show was recently rebooted with a Jimmy Fallon version, but Jimmy Fallon doesn't have to fill Carson's shoes. He only need fill Jay Leno's shoes, which is not nearly the task it would be to fill Carson's. Letterman would have been able to do it though, had they chosen him instead of Jay. He would have done it from the day he sat in that chair on the NBC set. Instead, we all lost touch with Dave when NBC turned their backs on him and he was exiled to CBS. Something changed and never got fixed.
Tuning in to see him interview Barack now feels like I'm watching Carson as a kid, from the darkness at the top of the stairs, hands clenched around the railing bars, trying to stay silent so my parents won't hear. The last remaining giant of Late Night has aged over the years, and yet his style is still unmistakably Letterman; a not-so-distant relative of the talk show hosts of the Jack Benny and Ed Sullivan era. And now, watching Letterman's show, so many years past it's prime, it's as if I've stumbled upon my parents old Tonight Show; a show that seemed so foreign to me as a very young kid, but somehow became as comforting as a televised late night summer baseball game. The music, Ed McMahon's voice introducing Johnny, the monologue loaded with references and double entendres, the guests that I didn't know or understand. The fact that Carson was such a legend by the time I was old enough to watch from the top of the stairs. Tonight's Letterman echoes that old familiar Carson format.
This is not the Letterman I grew up with, but it has its moments. You probably won't see Letterman flinging toast at his audience these days. Gone are the risky skits and edgy comedy. CBS' Letterman is actually a lamer, more conservative version of the NBC classic "Late Night with David Letterman." Now, THAT was a show I used to sneak downstairs at night to watch, just after my parents had gone to sleep. It was remarkably clever and interesting and biting and memorable. Dave Letterman was a young upstart compared to Carson, but his show felt more dangerous. It was a perfect mix: the time slot, the unremarkable photos of things in NYC with the Late Night logo, the low budget feel, the amazing writing, the guests. Everything about the old NBC Late Night show worked. There are remnants of that show in Dave's current CBS show, but they are merely echoes of a younger, hungrier man.
Tonight, Dave threw Obama softballs, and Barack spoke about what he came to speak about. It was enlightening, if rehearsed. Dave is the last talk show host of a three network era; a throwback to the days of the TV I remember as a kid, when if it wasn't on NBC, CBS, or ABC, it probably wasn't relevant. Yet he survives and thrives as a television personality. I have a hunch his ratings are going to start climbing again, now that people like me are old enough to embrace the nostalgia for a different television time, a time not long ago, when cable TV was new-fangled and still mostly terrible, a time when David Letterman was on the very cutting edge of Late Night network television. I suppose a part of me misses those times.
He may have mellowed out over the past fifteen years, but you know what? Maybe part of the reason I'm drawn back after all this time... is because I have too.